Content continues after advertisement

A Tale of Two Training Methods

Clinician's Brief (Capsule)


|July 2014

Sign in to Print/View PDF

This exploratory study compared the effects of 2 training methods on the behavioral welfare of pet dogs and the dog–owner relationship. The first method is based on positive reinforcement (appearance of appetite stimulus) and the second on negative reinforcement (disappearance of aversive stimulus). Both training methods are based on operant conditioning, which entails an animal learning that responses to instructions or stimuli have consequences.

This is the first direct observational behavioral study in nonworking pet dogs, as previous studies in pet dogs were based on questionnaires only. This study focused on the dogs’ on-leash behavior and ability to obey the sit command and evaluated the subjects for signs of stress and attentive behavior to the owners. The impacts of the methods were evaluated during advanced training classes to avoid the effects of training novelty and to have more consistency from owners and less confusion from subjects.

The dogs trained using negative reinforcement (n = 26) showed signs of stress and lowered body postures. Subjects trained with positive reinforcement-based methods (n = 24) showed increased attentiveness toward owners, as measured by frequency of gazes at the owner. Avoidance behaviors measured were not statistically significant. Further analyses are necessary to assess whether field training results are applicable to home training results. Study results suggested that positive reinforcement-
based training is less stressful to dogs and potentially more beneficial for dogs’ welfare and the dog–owner relationship.


Training is an important aspect of raising a dog and should enhance the dog–owner bond. This study showed that the training methods used can affect the relationship between the dog and owner. Reward-based training is enjoyable for the dog
and positively enhances the relationship between dog and owner. Finding the right trainer is the first step to success. The AVSAB’s How to Choose a Trainer handout offers excellent suggestions for owners to ensure that training is an enjoyable learning experience for their pet.—Sandra Sawchuk, DVM, MS


Effects of 2 training methods on stress-related behaviors of the dogs (Canis familiaris) and on the dog-owner relationship. Deldalle S, Gaunet F. J VET BEHAV 9:58-65, 2014.

For global readers, a calculator to convert laboratory values, dosages, and other measurements to SI units can be found here.

All Clinician's Brief content is reviewed for accuracy at the time of publication. Previously published content may not reflect recent developments in research and practice.

Material from Clinician's Brief may not be reproduced, distributed, or used in whole or in part without prior permission of Educational Concepts, LLC. For questions or inquiries please contact us.


Clinician's Brief:
The Podcast
Listen as host Alyssa Watson, DVM, talks with the authors of your favorite Clinician’s Brief articles. Dig deeper and explore the conversations behind the content here.
Clinician's Brief provides relevant diagnostic and treatment information for small animal practitioners. It has been ranked the #1 most essential publication by small animal veterinarians for 9 years.*

*2007-2017 PERQ and Essential Media Studies

© 2023 Educational Concepts, L.L.C. dba Brief Media ™ All Rights Reserved. Terms & Conditions | DMCA Copyright | Privacy Policy | Acceptable Use Policy